dewgong pokemon card Single XY - EVOLUTIONS (Reverse Holo) Water Colorless 1999 Pokemon Game 25 Dewgong

It has a fantasy theme and has been around for decades

More specifically, how are your opponents interacting with your cards and creatures

For this list I take a very liberal approach to cycles, prioritizing cycles that were somehow played in Constructed and are relevant to this day, and sometimes the cards will be from different sets (a super-cycle)

Grief $44 Grief kept a high price after dodging the ban hammer, so this reprint is pretty great, even if the supply isnt super high

Many cards provide benefits when chaos ensues, so if you have extra mana lying around, its often worth using it to roll the planar die extra times